Anaglyph’s Anime Appraisals

Kanon 10 or The Erosion of My Manliness by Anime

Filed under: Anime, Kanon — December 20, 2006 @ 8:41 am

First, big spoiler for Kanon ahead. Stay away if you don’t want to be spoiled. Spoiler on collision course. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.

Back when I was about seven or eight I read a book at school called Abandoned. It was about a kitten that was discarded at the roadside by its owners and about its struggle to survive. It wasn’t particularly pleasant reading for a young boy who loved animals and who had a cat of his own. This poor animal really suffered, often in horribly graphic ways, but I struggled on with the book. Finally, at the last chapter it seemed that there would be a happy ending. The cat was taken in by a kind family and given a loving home, and it seemed that all that pain was worth it in the end. And then one day the cat was run down by a car. As it lay by the roadside in agony the vet was called for, but nothing could be done and the poor cat was put to sleep.

I suppose the author might have felt his novel was “character building” by punching young children in the face with the cruel realities of life, but I hated that book, and I still do. It was sadistic. After I finished reading the last miserable page I had to hurry from the classroom and hide in the toilets to cry.

And now it’s happening all over again!

Okay, I don’t hate Kanon, but damn is it manipulative. From the moment Makoto was introduced we were expertly played. From her cutely ineffectual attempts to get revenge on Yuuichi, to her cute and increasingly apparent devotion to him, to her cute shyness, to her cute “auuu”s, to her general overwhelming cuteness. And beyond the cuteness we learn that she’s sacrificed her life to be with Yuuichi one last time. And on top of that they play the helpless dying animal card as well!

Makoto

This sort of thing would have the bile rising in my throat normally but somehow anime gets away with it, and not only does it get away with it, I had to sit through the episode struggling to hold back the tears. It should be maudlin but somehow Yuuichi’s selfless efforts to care for and bring a little happiness to Makoto during her last days of life, somehow Makoto’s regression to a child-like state as her borrowed humanity dissipates, somehow the final tender moments on the hill as she dies in his arms, somehow it all manages to barely sidestep mawkishness and…

Yuuichi and Makoto on the hill

I have been demanned by anime.

I should have seen the warning signs when I became devoted to Marimite. How can any man hope to retain his masculinity when he adores a series about a bunch of Catholic schoolgirls and the intricacies of their relationships? I tried to tell myself that it was full of lesbian subtext so it was all right, and Sei was a real lesbian and a rebel too - she was cool. All manly men are keen on lesbians - right? So yeah, maybe watching a school girl angsting about whether to give chocolates to her oneesama or not was a bit emasculating but it was balanced by the yuri subtext. Or so I fondly imagined.

I barely noticed the flagging state of my manhood by the time I started watching Ginban Kaleidoscope, a series about a girl who’s star is rising in the world of ice skating. Is there anything less manly than ice skating? Sadly yes. Instead of heeding the warning signs I continued on oblivious, watching the series to the end, whereupon I was moved by the bittersweet ending. Oh lordy…

Then came Otoboku. About a guy in a dress. Does anything more need to be said?

And now this. Watching anime has put me in serious danger of weeping like a little boy over the death of a cartoon fox-girl.

Graph of my drooping manhood

The line must be drawn here. This far, no further!

Tomorrow I’m going to build a shed. A shed to house my power tools. A shed built by power tools for power tools. Then I’m going to make a bonfire with the left over wood. And I’ll barbeque some meat while it’s burning. Maybe by taking these actions, just maybe I can save what little manly dignity I have remaining.

Awww hell - who am I kidding? I’ll be weeping my way through the rest of Kanon no doubt. At least it can’t get any worse than this - right? Right?

6 Comments »

  1. badger11:

    Hey, I’ll admit it, I cried like a little kid who had his ice cream cone drop to the ground. Its hard not to watch some shows and not become attached to certain characters. And Kanon is certainly one of those shows designed to manipulate emotions by presenting us with vulnerable characters. And KyoAni has done a good job with Kanon. It’d take a robot not to become attached to a spirited girl who lost her memories only to see her spirit ebb away. She lost her memory (and now we know why)and then her “life”. What was nice is that KyoAni showed her in a Spring field. I choose to look at that last scene as a positive (even though I teared up a lot at that scene).

    Ok, now I’m off to a bar to do something manly, like piss off some Hell’s Angels. Oh, and don’t forget to measure twice before you cut when you’re building the shed. ;-)

  2. ryuuu:

    don’t fight it ^^ manliness is overrated. marimite is awesome. otoboku is awesome. kanon is awesome. welcome to our side. BANZAI BANZAI BANZAI !!!!!

  3. Anaglyph:

    “What was nice is that KyoAni showed her in a Spring field. I choose to look at that last scene as a positive (even though I teared up a lot at that scene).”

    Yeah, glad they included that. It would have just been too depressing otherwise. Not sure exactly how much meaning can be derived from that shot, but it’s comforting to imagine Makoto’s still out there somewhere in some form. It does seem to be a show about the miraculous, so perhaps it’s not too farfetched.

    @ryuuu - To be honest, I’ve never really been that much of a manly man. Certainly not a 100% on a graph. ;)

  4. Kari Manninen:

    Having feelings isn`t unmanly.Being hard,cynical,cruel and devoid of feelings is inhuman.Please do not get wrong ideas about what being manly really means.History os full of proof what damage that psychopatic idea of manliness causes.

  5. Kari Manninen:

    i mean`t “history is full….”

  6. haru:

    i love ur graph!!!!!!!!!

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

You can hide spoilers with the spoiler tag (as seen below). Name and e-mail address are not required.

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <spoiler> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>